If everyone is a hipster, then nobody is. Hipster has become a style, a fashion.
When a couple guys started buttoning their top button, I thought it was good looking. All you followers that now do so, it's not cool anymore. A hipster isn't a follower. If you really want to be a hipster, stop buttoning the top button. But who really cares. It's okay not to be a hipster. I'm not one.
Some hipsters take it too far. Guys, stop dressing like girls. Don't roll your pants up into capris and wear cute little boots. Be a man.
Hipster shmipster.